SkinnyRx vs Remedy Meds: Which Weight Loss Provider Is For You?

When I decided to explore GLP-1 medications, I didn’t go straight to Josie. Before finding my fit, I tested the waters with a few providers, including SkinnyRx and Remedy Meds. I filled out their intake forms, looked at their pricing, and even waited for provider assignments. These experiences gave me valuable insight into how different telehealth companies operate—and why I ultimately landed on Josie instead.

This is my story, shared to help other women navigate the same choices with clarity and confidence.

Why I Started Looking

Like many women in perimenopause, I was dealing with unwanted weight gain. My hormones were all over the place, and while HRT helped bring balance, the extra pounds stuck around. I wanted to lose about 15 pounds, reduce inflammation, and finally get rid of the dreaded “meno belly.”

I kept reading that OBGYNs recommend pairing HRT with GLP-1s for stubborn midlife weight changes. That was the nudge I needed to start exploring providers.

My Experience With SkinnyRx

SkinnyRx has been one of the original GLP-1 telehealth providers and has been in business longer than many newer entrants, which speaks to their staying power. Their intake form was quick—five minutes tops—and asked the basics: weight, height, goal weight, and ID upload. Straightforward, but not overly detailed.

The pricing looked clear for the first month, with a low entry price that was appealing, though I wasn’t entirely sure what the ongoing costs would be. The main drawback for me personally was the wait time. It took about 48 hours before I was assigned a provider. During that time, I started looking elsewhere and didn’t move forward with them.

What I Liked ✅

• Quick intake form (5 minutes).
• Simple, straightforward process.
• Low entry price for the first month.
• One of the original GLP-1 providers with proven longevity.

What Could Be Improved ✨

• Clearer details on ongoing pricing after the first month.
• Faster response time for provider assignment.
• More personal touch in the communication.

My Experience With Remedy Meds

Remedy Meds has quickly become one of the more visible providers, even being ranked #1 on Forbes Health’s list of online weight loss programs. Their intake form was slightly longer—about seven minutes—but still very manageable. The difference I noticed was their speed of response. Within 24 hours, I was assigned a provider, which felt reassuring.

Their pricing was very transparent, which I appreciated, and communication felt professional. I didn’t complete the full telehealth consult because I discovered another provider I connected with more, but overall, I can see why Remedy Meds is so highly regarded.

What I Liked ✅

• Intake form easy to complete.
• Very transparent pricing.
• Assigned a provider within 24 hours.
• Ranked #1 on Forbes Health’s list of online weight loss programs.

What Could Be Improved ✨

• Intake process felt a little longer than others.
• While professional, the communication felt a bit standard — not as personal as I hoped.
• Didn’t get as far as the telehealth call, so I can’t speak to that part.

Why I Chose Josie Instead

While both SkinnyRx and Remedy Meds offered good experiences in their own ways, neither felt like the right fit for me personally. The biggest difference was how I found Josie. I didn’t see them in ads—I heard about them from a friend whose experience had been really positive. That felt more trustworthy than any advertisement.

What stood out with Josie was:

• Their focus on menopause and midlife women, which made me feel understood.
• The fast turnaround time—I didn’t wait long to move forward.
• The team felt genuinely caring, not just going through the motions.

What I Liked ✅

• Menopause-focused, which felt tailored to me.
• Low BMI approvals.
• Very fast turnaround time.
• Caring communication — felt like they understood midlife women.
• Recommended by a friend, which gave me instant trust.

What Could Be Improved ✨

• Not as widely known as other providers, so you may need to dig a bit to learn about them.
• Limited availability depending on your state, so always check coverage.

Lessons Learned From Trying SkinnyRx and Remedy Meds

Exploring multiple providers taught me what matters when making this decision:

• Pay attention to response times. A provider who gets back quickly makes a big difference.
• Look for pricing clarity. Transparency helps you feel confident about the commitment.
• Trust your instincts. The right provider feels like a partner, not just a prescription.

My best advice? Narrow down your top three providers, fill out the forms, and see how each one feels. You’ll know when you’ve found the right fit.

Side-by-Side Comparison Table

Key differences between SkinnyRx, Remedy Meds and Join Josie:

Feature	SkinnyRx	Remedy Meds	Josie
Longevity (time in business)	✅	✖️	✖️
Pricing transparency	✅	✅	✅
Response time	✅	✅	✅
Forbes #1 ranking	✖️	✅	✖️
Menopause focus	✖️	✖️	✅
Microdose options	✖️	✖️	✅
Oral tirzepatide	✖️	✖️	✅
Initial discount	✅	✅	✅

Keys to Success When Choosing a GLP-1 Provider

1. Expect a realistic timeline. Most providers deliver medications within 7–14 days after approval. Some are faster, some take longer. Larger providers like SkinnyRx and Remedy Meds serve big customer bases, which can sometimes cause delays.
2. Understand consult fees. Some providers charge for the consultation even if you decide not to move forward with medications. Be sure you’re comfortable with your choice before booking a consult.
3. Know your options. Beyond traditional compounded injectables, some providers, like Josie, also offer microdose options. These can be a gentler way to start GLP-1s, especially if you’re looking to reduce inflammation, support longevity, or ease into the process.
4. Match the provider to your needs. Cost, speed, personalization, and focus all matter. There’s no single “best” provider—just the one that fits you best.

Final Thoughts

Both SkinnyRx and Remedy Meds are solid, reputable providers that I’d recommend considering. SkinnyRx has longevity, a simple process, and a low first-month price, while Remedy Meds is praised for transparency and speed, even being recognized by Forbes Health. For me, Josie stood out because they were menopause-focused and felt more personal, but that doesn’t make them the only answer.

At the end of the day, the best choice depends on what matters most to you—whether it’s cost, speed, support, or a provider who understands your stage of life.